The 1991 Fleer Baseball set includes 720 base cards, produced during a period of overproduction in the card industry. Despite mass printing, specific cards from this set remain valuable due to player popularity, scarcity in mint condition, and specific grading trends. Cards graded PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 have significantly higher values in secondary markets.
The design is distinctive with bright yellow borders and plain player images. The set lacks premium inserts but includes subsets like Pro Visions and All-Star Team. Some error cards and rare variations also impact market values. The most valuable cards from this set are typically tied to Hall of Famers, rookies, and condition-sensitive issues.
Why Are Some 1991 Fleer Cards Valuable?
The most valuable 1991 Fleer baseball cards gain value through a combination of player legacy, population rarity in gem mint condition, and collector demand. High-grade examples of key player cards often attract investment interest due to scarcity despite overall high production.
PSA population reports show few PSA 10s for many cards due to centering issues and print defects. Players like Ken Griffey Jr., Barry Bonds, and Nolan Ryan anchor the value in this set. Additionally, Pro Visions inserts offer limited supply with standout player art, adding collectible interest.
Grading significantly impacts card value. For example, a common raw card worth under $1 may exceed $100 if graded PSA 10. Thus, grading outcomes are critical in defining market worth.
50 Most Valuable 1991 Fleer Baseball Cards
. 1991 Fleer Kirby Puckett #232 (Approx. $5–10)
The Kirby Puckett card from the 1991 Fleer set sells for around five to ten dollars in ungraded condition. Puckett was already a Hall of Famer and fan favorite by then. This card shows him in action with a yellow border and clean photo. The primary value comes from his legacy and the card’s condition, as corners and centering greatly affect grading. High grade PSA 9 or better specimens fetch double or more the ungraded price.
2. 1991 Fleer Ken Griffey Jr. #1 (Approx. $8–15)
The number one card featuring Ken Griffey Jr sells for eight to fifteen dollars ungraded. Griffey Jr was one of the most popular players of that era. This card’s appeal comes from its star power and vintage status. Cards with sharp edges and bright gloss stand out at shows and auctions. In PSA 10 grade, prices may reach thirty dollars or more.
3. 1991 Fleer Frank Thomas #804 (Approx. $3–7)
Frank Thomas’s card sells for approximately three to seven dollars ungraded. Known as The Big Hurt he became a dominant force in the 1990s. His Fleer card includes a clear image and team logo. Serious collectors look for perfect corners and sharp printing. Condition remains critical when it comes to flipping or investing in this card.
4. 1991 Fleer Barry Bonds #390 (Approx. $4–9)
Barry Bonds’s 1991 Fleer card ranges from four to nine dollars in ungraded form. Bonds was at the peak of his career and a household name. The design highlights him batting with bright yellow borders. Collectors value this card primarily based on autograph interest and print quality. High grade copies continue to appreciate over time.
5. 1991 Fleer Roger Clemens #630 (Approx. $3–6)
Roger Clemens’s card sells between three and six dollars ungraded. Clemens dominated as a pitcher during that era. This card includes his pitching image and pitcher stats on the back. Its value increases with sharp corners and no surface wear. PSA 9 examples attract collectors who focus on pitching legends.
6. 1991 Fleer Mark McGwire #349 (Approx. $2–5)
Mark McGwire’s card currently sells for around two to five dollars ungraded. Known for his home run prowess McGwire has strong collector appeal. The card features him in batting stance with yellow border. Condition and centering define its value in the grading market. High grade near mint plus examples move for higher premiums.
7. 1991 Fleer Cal Ripken Jr. #495 (Approx. $3–8)
Cal Ripken Jr.’s card sells for three to eight dollars ungraded. The Iron Man streak puts his memorabilia in demand. The card shows him fielding with team identification visible. Clear surface and intact corners determine condition grades. PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 versions can command double the ungraded price.
8. 1991 Fleer Nolan Ryan #77 (Approx. $2–6)
Nolan Ryan’s card ranges between two and six dollars ungraded. Ryan was a generation of pitching dominance. The photo features him in mid-pitch with bold borders. Authenticity and surface gloss are key quality markers. PSA high grades continue to grow in interest among pitching history collectors.
9. 1991 Fleer Ozzie Smith #31 (Approx. $3–7)
Ozzie Smith’s card sells for three to seven dollars ungraded. His defensive wizardry made him a fan favorite. The card shows him fielding with glove extended. Crisp image and even borders matter in assessing grades. High grade examples often appreciate steadily with market trends.
10. 1991 Fleer Randy Johnson Rookie #641 (Approx. $5–12)
Randy Johnson rookie card sells for about five to twelve dollars ungraded. As a future Hall of Famer this rookie holds long-term value. The card photograph shows him mid-pitch wearing early Mariners uniform. Centers of interest include rookie designation and condition such as no print spots. PSA 9 or PSA 10 copies significantly exceed the base price.
11. 1991 Fleer Jose Canseco #110 (Approx. $2–5)
Jose Canseco’s 1991 Fleer card sells for two to five dollars ungraded. Canseco was one of the biggest names in early 90s baseball. His card features a batting pose in the Oakland A’s uniform. Condition-sensitive elements include centering and edge wear. PSA 10 versions can sell for over fifteen dollars due to low population.
12. 1991 Fleer Ryne Sandberg #10 (Approx. $3–6)
Ryne Sandberg’s card typically sells for three to six dollars in raw condition. Sandberg’s consistent fielding and batting success anchor his collectible status. The card shows him mid-swing with clear team branding. Values increase notably for PSA 9 and above. Sandberg remains a respected Hall of Famer with a loyal collector base.
13. 1991 Fleer Bo Jackson #461 (Approx. $4–8)
Bo Jackson’s card commands between four and eight dollars. The card shows Jackson during his hybrid MLB-NFL popularity peak. He’s pictured in batting action, easily recognizable due to his athletic build. Grading plays a major role, especially for PSA 10s, which exceed twenty dollars. Popularity and cultural relevance maintain this card’s demand.
14. 1991 Fleer Tony Gwynn #321 (Approx. $2–5)
Tony Gwynn’s card sells for about two to five dollars. The card features a close-up batting image that reflects Gwynn’s status as a contact-hitting legend. Corners and gloss are common grading pitfalls. Cards in pristine condition with strong centering appeal to condition-focused collectors. PSA 10s reach $15 or more.
15. 1991 Fleer Don Mattingly #555 (Approx. $3–7)
Don Mattingly’s card holds value in the three to seven dollar range. As a Yankees icon, Mattingly’s cards consistently retain interest. The card displays him preparing to swing with detailed background contrast. PSA 9 and PSA 10 examples carry value multiples of raw copies. Scarcity in top condition drives pricing.
16. 1991 Fleer Deion Sanders #454 (Approx. $4–10)
Deion Sanders’ dual-sport appeal helps this card reach four to ten dollars ungraded. The image captures him in a batting stance for the Braves. The card’s sharp edges and surface are critical for investment-grade copies. PSA 10 examples regularly sell for twenty-five dollars or more. The unique athletic crossover ensures long-term interest.
17. 1991 Fleer Rickey Henderson #326 (Approx. $3–6)
Rickey Henderson’s card ranges from three to six dollars. Known for his base-stealing prowess, Henderson’s cards are widely collected. The Fleer edition shows him running with clean framing. Market value depends heavily on print registration and corner sharpness. PSA 10 versions have low population and reach up to twenty dollars.
18. 1991 Fleer Sammy Sosa #558 (Approx. $5–12)
Sammy Sosa’s early-career card often sells for five to twelve dollars. This pre-steroid era card shows Sosa with the White Sox. The card holds rookie-like value among collectors despite not being a true rookie. Grading demand is high for gem mint copies. Market interest rises with Hall of Fame debates.
19. 1991 Fleer George Brett #195 (Approx. $2–5)
George Brett’s card falls into the two to five dollar range. The design includes Brett fielding with classic yellow framing. Grading difficulties arise due to print marks and soft corners. PSA 9 and 10 cards exceed ten dollars due to supply scarcity. Brett’s Hall of Fame status supports consistent demand.
20. 1991 Fleer Chipper Jones Rookie (Pro Visions) #6 of 9 (Approx. $8–20)
Chipper Jones’ Pro Visions rookie insert is one of the set’s most valuable at eight to twenty dollars ungraded. As a future Hall of Famer, early Jones cards carry weight in investment circles. The Pro Visions subset includes illustrated artistic versions, unlike base cards. Sharp corners and no surface flaking are critical for grading. PSA 10s have sold for over forty dollars.
21. 1991 Fleer Greg Maddux #361 (Approx. $3–7)
Greg Maddux’s 1991 Fleer card sells for three to seven dollars in ungraded form. The card features him mid-pitch for the Cubs, with a clean yellow border. Maddux’s legacy as a control pitcher elevates long-term demand. Grading challenges include centering and minor print blemishes. PSA 10 copies can reach twenty dollars due to low gem mint populations.
22. 1991 Fleer Andre Dawson #13 (Approx. $2–5)
Andre Dawson’s card typically sells between two and five dollars. The image presents Dawson batting for the Cubs, highlighting his power-hitting profile. The bright background and borders are prone to showing wear. PSA 9 and 10 cards have a modest premium due to Dawson’s Hall of Fame career. Collectors target clean surface and sharp edges.
23. 1991 Fleer Jeff Bagwell Rookie #398 (Approx. $6–15)
Jeff Bagwell’s rookie card from this set is valued between six and fifteen dollars. Though not a flagship rookie, this early issue gains importance from Bagwell’s Hall of Fame induction. The card captures him during a swing, framed tightly. Centering inconsistencies are common, reducing PSA 10 availability. High grades push past twenty-five dollars.
24. 1991 Fleer Harold Baines #575 (Approx. $2–4)
Harold Baines’s card is valued at two to four dollars. While not a high-demand player, his Hall of Fame status maintains collector interest. The image features Baines at bat for the A’s, with a classic pose. The card is susceptible to minor chipping along the edges. PSA 10 examples rarely exceed ten dollars.
25. 1991 Fleer Dave Winfield #73 (Approx. $3–6)
Dave Winfield’s card sells for three to six dollars ungraded. Winfield appears in Yankees gear, batting against a blurred outfield. The design is simple, but fans value it for career recognition. Surface scuffing reduces grading chances. PSA 9 or better cards are preferred by collectors who focus on career totals.
26. 1991 Fleer Paul Molitor #548 (Approx. $2–4)
Paul Molitor’s card ranges between two and four dollars. The card shows Molitor mid-swing for the Brewers. A clear, centered image and clean gloss are essential for grading. Molitor’s impact as a clutch hitter adds collector relevance. PSA 10s remain uncommon and can reach above fifteen dollars.
27. 1991 Fleer Dennis Eckersley #422 (Approx. $3–6)
Dennis Eckersley’s card is valued between three and six dollars. Featured as an Oakland A’s closer, this card shows Eckersley in full pitching motion. As a dominant relief pitcher, his value is supported by ERA records and postseason success. Centering and yellow border wear are grading challenges. PSA 10s attract niche interest from bullpen collectors.
28. 1991 Fleer Willie McGee #407 (Approx. $2–3)
Willie McGee’s card typically sells for two to three dollars. Although not a Hall of Famer, McGee’s popularity in the 80s and 90s gives the card a steady presence in collections. The image shows him running bases, emphasizing his speed. Value is modest unless in pristine condition. PSA 10 versions can exceed ten dollars in auctions.
29. 1991 Fleer Alan Trammell #431 (Approx. $2–4)
Alan Trammell’s card is priced around two to four dollars. The design shows Trammell fielding for the Tigers, representing his defensive strength. Popularity surged post-Hall of Fame induction. Edge quality and print alignment define condition premiums. Top graded cards gain incremental value year over year.
30. 1991 Fleer Robin Yount #421 (Approx. $3–6)
Robin Yount’s card commands three to six dollars ungraded. He’s shown in a batting position for Milwaukee, with a composed expression. The card gains value from his two-time MVP status. Centering issues reduce gem mint supply. PSA 10 copies are valued above twenty dollars.
31. 1991 Fleer John Smoltz #416 (Approx. $3–7)
John Smoltz’s card sells between three and seven dollars ungraded. The photo shows him in mid-pitch wearing Braves colors. As a Cy Young winner and postseason standout, Smoltz maintains solid collector demand. Card value increases with sharp corners and vibrant surface. PSA 10 versions regularly exceed twenty dollars due to condition scarcity.
32. 1991 Fleer Dave Justice #690 (Approx. $4–10)
Dave Justice’s card commands four to ten dollars. Featured in the Braves uniform, the image captures his early-career momentum. His 1990 Rookie of the Year award adds context to this card’s relevance. Popularity peaked during Atlanta’s 90s dominance. PSA 10 copies can cross twenty dollars due to nostalgic appeal.
33. 1991 Fleer Wade Boggs #380 (Approx. $3–6)
Wade Boggs’s card is valued between three and six dollars. Shown mid-swing, Boggs is recognized for consistent high averages. Collectors favor this card for completeness in Hall of Fame collections. The card’s surface and centering affect grading potential. PSA 9 or better cards draw premium bids.
34. 1991 Fleer Dwight Gooden #533 (Approx. $2–4)
Dwight Gooden’s card sells for two to four dollars. The image reflects his time with the Mets during a career recovery phase. Although not a Hall of Famer, Gooden retains hobby interest due to 80s peak performance. Grading is often hindered by edge wear. PSA 10 examples remain affordable but relatively scarce.
35. 1991 Fleer Tim Raines #14 (Approx. $2–5)
Tim Raines’s card ranges from two to five dollars. Shown in a running stance, the image highlights his speed-based game. Raines’s Hall of Fame induction boosted values across his card portfolio. Yellow borders show chipping easily, limiting gem mint population. PSA 10s can fetch fifteen dollars or more.
36. 1991 Fleer Eric Davis #90 (Approx. $3–6)
Eric Davis’s card is valued at three to six dollars. Captured in batting form, the card reflects Davis’s reputation for speed and power. Though not a Hall of Famer, he remains popular among Reds collectors. Value hinges on surface quality and centering. PSA 10 versions occasionally break twenty dollars.
37. 1991 Fleer Andy Van Slyke #538 (Approx. $2–4)
Andy Van Slyke’s card typically sells for two to four dollars. The photo features him fielding with the Pirates during his All-Star stretch. His defensive skills and popularity in Pittsburgh fuel moderate collector demand. Clean gloss and crisp corners are rare in this issue. PSA 9 or 10 versions are low in number.
38. 1991 Fleer Benito Santiago #215 (Approx. $2–4)
Benito Santiago’s card is priced at two to four dollars. Displaying him catching in full gear, this card highlights his defensive reputation. The value is mostly regional and based on 90s nostalgia. Grading demand is lower but PSA 10s do exist and may reach ten dollars. Surface wear is a consistent problem.
39. 1991 Fleer Ellis Burks #273 (Approx. $2–3)
Ellis Burks’s card ranges between two and three dollars. A steady contributor during the 90s, Burks’s Fleer issue is under the radar. Featured batting with the Red Sox, the card is cleanly laid out. Collectors seek high grade examples mainly for team sets. PSA 10s are rare and typically auction-driven.
40. 1991 Fleer Steve Avery #171 (Approx. $3–6)
Steve Avery’s card is valued at three to six dollars. He was a rising star for the Braves rotation in the early 90s. The card captures him mid-windup with strong visual clarity. Although he never reached full stardom, his early cards have modest collector demand. PSA 10s can bring in higher prices during nostalgia waves.
41. 1991 Fleer Kevin Appier Rookie #513 (Approx. $3–6)
Kevin Appier’s rookie card from the 1991 Fleer set is typically valued at three to six dollars in ungraded condition. The card captures Appier early in his MLB career with the Kansas City Royals. As one of the more underappreciated pitchers of the 90s, Appier’s rookie has become a niche target for team and rookie collectors.
Despite not being a Hall of Famer, Appier had multiple strong seasons, including a 1993 campaign where he led the American League in ERA. High-grade versions are limited due to typical Fleer issues like yellow border chipping and centering flaws. PSA 10 examples can surpass twenty dollars, though availability remains low.
42. 1991 Fleer Lance Parrish #156 (Approx. $2–3)
Lance Parrish’s card from this set generally sells for two to three dollars. Parrish, a multi-time All-Star catcher, is featured during his time with the Angels. Known for his power behind the plate, his Fleer card is often included in complete set builds and catcher-themed collections.
While it doesn’t command high market value, it remains a steady card due to his long MLB tenure. Like most cards in this release, centering and border edge quality significantly influence grading outcomes. PSA 10 versions are uncommon but rarely exceed fifteen dollars even in top condition.
43. 1991 Fleer Ron Gant #435 (Approx. $2–5)
Ron Gant’s 1991 Fleer card is valued between two and five dollars. As a key contributor for the Braves, Gant’s mix of power and speed made him a standout during the early 1990s. His card features a batting shot that aligns with his offensive profile.
Collectors drawn to Atlanta’s early-90s core frequently pursue high-grade examples of this card. Though not a Hall of Famer, Gant’s two 30–30 seasons in 1990 and 1991 elevate interest. PSA 10 versions have sold for up to twenty dollars, mostly driven by condition rarity.
44. 1991 Fleer Darryl Strawberry #290 (Approx. $3–7)
Darryl Strawberry’s card usually sells for three to seven dollars, reflecting his enduring fan base despite an up-and-down career. The card features a clean image of Strawberry mid-swing, dressed in Dodgers colors. It’s a visual departure from his Mets era, offering a unique appeal.
Strawberry was a key figure in 80s baseball and retains collector loyalty. The card’s value is mostly influenced by personal nostalgia and regional fandom. Grading is hindered by surface quality and centering, but PSA 10s occasionally sell in the twenty to thirty dollar range.
45. 1991 Fleer Cecil Fielder #345 (Approx. $2–5)
Cecil Fielder’s card is priced at two to five dollars ungraded. The image showcases Fielder during his powerful stretch with the Tigers. Coming off back-to-back 50 and 44 home run seasons, his 1991 cards had real-time relevance.
Though his career declined later, this Fleer issue captures him at peak production. Collectors look for well-centered copies with clean borders. In gem mint grade, values approach fifteen to twenty dollars, especially when paired with other Tigers stars of the era.
46. 1991 Fleer Will Clark #180 (Approx. $3–6)
Will Clark’s Fleer card is typically valued between three and six dollars. A five-time All-Star and Silver Slugger, Clark’s consistent performance makes his cards popular among fans of 80s and 90s baseball. The image shows him in a clean Giants uniform with poised batting stance.
Clark had a strong fan following and played with intensity, which enhances the card’s desirability. Sharp printing and centered framing are necessary for high grades. PSA 10s are limited but generally don’t surpass twenty-five dollars in sales.
47. 1991 Fleer Brian McRae Rookie #365 (Approx. $2–4)
Brian McRae’s rookie card from this set holds a value of two to four dollars. As the son of Hal McRae and a dependable outfielder for Kansas City, Brian’s early cards are commonly included in Royals-focused collections. The photo shows him fielding with strong action framing.
While not an elite player, McRae had several productive seasons. This rookie card stands as a moderate-value item mostly sought in complete rookie subsets. High-grade versions are rarely submitted, but PSA 10s can cross ten dollars in the right market.
48. 1991 Fleer Tino Martinez Rookie #688 (Approx. $4–10)
Tino Martinez’s rookie card is worth around four to ten dollars. Though he found most of his success later with the Yankees, this early Mariners-era card holds long-term value. It shows Martinez during a swing, wearing a dark Seattle uniform.
The card gains appeal from his clutch postseason performances and four World Series titles. Rookie card completists target PSA 10 examples, which often sell between twenty to thirty-five dollars, especially in Yankees markets. Condition issues limit population in top grades.
49. 1991 Fleer Pro Visions Ryne Sandberg #4 of 9 (Approx. $8–18)
Ryne Sandberg’s Pro Visions insert card carries a value between eight and eighteen dollars. These artist-rendered inserts differ visually from base cards and are far less common. The Sandberg card displays him in a surreal baseball environment with high visual appeal.
Collectors often seek the full Pro Visions set, and Sandberg is a highlight. These inserts are grading-sensitive due to black border edges that show chipping. PSA 10 examples are rare and can fetch up to forty dollars in competitive auctions.
50. 1991 Fleer Pro Visions Cal Ripken Jr. #9 of 9 (Approx. $10–25)
Cal Ripken Jr.’s Pro Visions card is one of the highest-valued cards from the 1991 Fleer release, priced at ten to twenty-five dollars ungraded. This insert features Ripken in a stylized fielding scene with intricate artwork. The unique design distinguishes it from standard issues.
As one of baseball’s most respected figures, Ripken’s memorabilia commands premium attention. Pro Visions cards are condition-sensitive due to full-bleed design. PSA 10 examples are uncommon and can reach fifty dollars or more depending on auction exposure.